Episode 168

full
Published on:

23rd Apr 2025

BSG S2E2 - Everyone Hates Rick Berman

In this week's episode, Laura and Xhafer discuss the harrowing events of Battlestar Galactica Season 2, Episode 2: Valley of Darkness. Laura warns against sticking a gun in your pants. Xhafer braces Laura for the next inevitable messed-up thing the show will throw at her.

Join us for more discussion on the discord @ https://discord.gg/MUHKDDk6TN

Transcript
Xhafer:

Hey listener, quick content warning.

2

:

This is the one where we have the dream

sequence where Adam drowns a baby.

3

:

We're gonna talk about it.

4

:

If you don't want to hear us

talk about it, I don't blame

5

:

you to be perfectly honest.

6

:

It's jarring as fuck.

7

:

Uh, So we'll just catch you next week.

8

:

No worries.

9

:

Uh, But we just wanted to give you

a heads up that that's this episode.

10

:

Laura: Hello and welcome to Who Are You?

11

:

We're a reasonably well done sci-fi

watch cast by a couple of friends who are

12

:

watching 2000 fours Battlestar Galactica.

13

:

I'm Laura

14

:

Xhafer: And I'm Jair.

15

:

Laura: and Jennifer.

16

:

I have

17

:

a question.

18

:

Xhafer: Oh, what's up?

19

:

Laura: Is.

20

:

This episode, kind of like season twos 33.

21

:

Xhafer: It feels that way, doesn't

22

:

Laura: It was pretty suspenseful.

23

:

Xhafer: It was

24

:

Laura: like suspense.

25

:

Xhafer: So, um.

26

:

I think I mentioned it a while ago that

I had picked up the Mark Altman, book

27

:

about the making of Battlestar Galactica.

28

:

Laura: Right.

29

:

Uhhuh.

30

:

Xhafer: Um, this is the guy who did, if

you see those like, 50 year journeys or

31

:

whatever, there's these two volume Star

Trek book that's like seven, 800 pages.

32

:

There's these massive things all

about the making of Star Trek from.

33

:

Pre TOS through to, I think it ends

sometime around the JJ Abrams movies.

34

:

Laura: Oh, okay.

35

:

So it goes that far.

36

:

Xhafer: I think, I think it goes that far.

37

:

I don't think it makes it to

Discovery, but I haven't read them.

38

:

But I remember them

being out for a while at

39

:

Laura: Oh no, I've seen this thing.

40

:

Yeah.

41

:

Yeah.

42

:

Xhafer: so in 2018 he went

and did interviews with.

43

:

Everyone he could for Battlestar

Galactica original and remake

44

:

Laura: Mm-hmm.

45

:

Xhafer: and I have started reading this

just home, it's gotta be seven, 800 pages.

46

:

Laura: Wow.

47

:

Xhafer: I got super lucky.

48

:

I found a used copy online for $12.

49

:

If you look at this thing

on Amazon, it's 120.

50

:

Laura: Ooh,

51

:

Xhafer: It's, it's been outta print for.

52

:

Seven, eight years

53

:

Laura: Yeah.

54

:

Yeah.

55

:

Xhafer: and it's never

gonna get a reprint.

56

:

And I got a first edition hardcover for

12 bucks just by SC and used book sites.

57

:

So thrift books love that shit.

58

:

Laura: In, in a couple of years.

59

:

Can I borrow that?

60

:

Xhafer: for sure.

61

:

I am actually hoping to be done with

it before I see you this summer.

62

:

Laura: I know, but I can't take it from

63

:

you this summer.

64

:

Xhafer: Oh yeah.

65

:

Oh no, actually I can,

66

:

Laura: spoily

67

:

Xhafer: I can actually tell you for

sure because I started reading, I

68

:

did, I skipped the original making

of the original Battlestar stuff

69

:

'cause I wanted to get to things

that we could talk about on pod.

70

:

And I did, I started

reading this book yesterday.

71

:

I read about a hundred pages.

72

:

Laura: Okay.

73

:

' Xhafer: cause I, I read very quickly.

74

:

Laura: I imagine there's

some stuff in there that we

75

:

can talk about.

76

:

Yeah.

77

:

Xhafer: there's stuff about this

78

:

episode.

79

:

Laura: Oh, well that's handy.

80

:

Xhafer: Specifically about the, like

wizardry of the set crew to move, like,

81

:

so when they built the Battlestar sets,

well, when they, when they started

82

:

making the show, a lot of the things

were, whenever Star Trek turned right,

83

:

were turning left because a lot of the

feelings of this show from Ron Moore

84

:

were a very coming out of a very negative

experience leading being Star Trek,

85

:

Laura: Mm.

86

:

Yeah.

87

:

Xhafer: and, uh, man, everyone has talked

shit about Rick Berman in this book.

88

:

It's so great.

89

:

Everyone hates Rick Berman.

90

:

people are talking about like.

91

:

Just like I hear Steven Bayers

just all like, man, you know,

92

:

like Brandon and, and Ron.

93

:

They're great dudes.

94

:

It's, it's a, you know, the Voyager

almost caught them, their friendship.

95

:

They, they had a really tough time

adjusting to different things and what

96

:

Ron wanted to do and all these things.

97

:

Ron was talking about doing, about

Voyager sustaining damage and keeping

98

:

damage about Voyager, meeting up with

like an alien flotilla and having to

99

:

escort them through space and stuff, and.

100

:

You know, at what point does

their culture stop being starlee?

101

:

Should they have elections?

102

:

Like why is Janeway just

always the captain and

103

:

unquestionable and all this shit?

104

:

And I'm just all like,

this is all Battlestar.

105

:

Every single thing he wanted to do

in Voyager, he did in Battlestar.

106

:

Laura: Yeah,

107

:

Xhafer: But one of the things.

108

:

Yeah, they, and they like

down to how it's shot.

109

:

Like they're talking about how Star Trek

does, like the establishing shot of the

110

:

room, the twofer, the closeup on one,

the closeup on the other, the twofer,

111

:

the establishing shot, like they do,

they followed this pattern and how they

112

:

tried so hard in their set design to

break these patterns to, to make it so

113

:

that you could do the West Wing style.

114

:

That we see so much of, and

because of that decision early

115

:

on led in this episode, a lot of

their hallways were very modular

116

:

Laura: Yeah.

117

:

Xhafer: so that they could dress up

one hallway 20 times by just moving the

118

:

set pieces around very quickly, which

119

:

Laura: There's a lot of

120

:

Xhafer: afford to make this episode.

121

:

Laura: Yeah.

122

:

No, I, I can definitely

see a difference visually.

123

:

Just thinking about it, it, it almost

seems like, I don't wanna say reality

124

:

TV 'cause that's not quite right, but

some of the shots feel very like reality

125

:

too intimate or not, not staged in

the way that Star Trek feels staged.

126

:

You know what I'm saying?

127

:

And especially when we go through

a lot of, lot of suspense and

128

:

chaos in this particular episode.

129

:

Should we tell the

people what episode we're

130

:

discussing?

131

:

Xhafer: we're watching season two,

episode two, valley of Darkness.

132

:

Laura: Not quite as like,

gripping a title as 33.

133

:

Like 33.

134

:

You wonder what's going on.

135

:

Like,

136

:

Xhafer: I mean, valley

Darkness is not a happy title.

137

:

Laura: It's not a happy title,

but it, it's not as like,

138

:

huh, what's happening here?

139

:

I, I kind of know something's dark.

140

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

141

:

Something's got for sure.

142

:

Billy.

143

:

It gets shut down by

d in our opening here.

144

:

Laura: Yeah.

145

:

Xhafer: As power immediately

goes out on the Galactica, gada

146

:

says this is a residual effect

of the virus in the system.

147

:

As LSO Captain Kelly let CIC

know that they have been boarded.

148

:

Laura: Billy really got hit below

the belt here in this opening scene.

149

:

Xhafer: Billy gets it rough here.

150

:

Uh, Not that he doesn't deserve

it, because if we remember his last

151

:

interaction with Dee was effectively using

her for information for the president.

152

:

Laura: Uh, Yeah.

153

:

Their last like, romantic

interaction, right?

154

:

Yeah, that's

155

:

true.

156

:

Xhafer: And he's on this ship right

now because his boss is in the brick.

157

:

Laura: Yeah, I wasn't clear

like, why is Billy on the ship?

158

:

Is he on the ship?

159

:

Like he's not in the bri with her.

160

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

161

:

Laura: So why did they

bring everyone over?

162

:

Did I miss something?

163

:

Xhafer: Um, I mean, they did talk about

how they had to cut into, colonial

164

:

One, so maybe there were some worries

about mechanical issues uh, on the

165

:

ship

166

:

Laura: not sound

167

:

anymore.

168

:

Yeah.

169

:

Xhafer: Maybe, maybe not as

many people should be on there.

170

:

And Billy volunteered, um, he might've

just gone with Rosaly because of.

171

:

Him being the chief of staff or whatever,

172

:

the page or assistant, whatever his

173

:

Laura: almost seems like Ty

should have like locked him

174

:

up somewhere though, right?

175

:

Xhafer: I would think so.

176

:

Laura: I, I would think Ty would do that.

177

:

Yeah.

178

:

Xhafer: I think if he's on the

ship, he's in the break for sure.

179

:

But maybe, just in a like.

180

:

I, I, I, I don't know why you'd

want Billy running around doing the

181

:

president's business on this ship,

182

:

Laura: Talking to your people.

183

:

Yeah.

184

:

Xhafer: yeah, like, but that's

probably what he'd be there to

185

:

do if he was not in the brig.

186

:

I don't understand that decision, but,

you know, uh, Ty fucks up a bunch, so

187

:

Laura: Yeah.

188

:

I mean.

189

:

We get Ty in this opening, just

like staring at Adama wishing he

190

:

was Adama or that Adama wasn't there

and he was there instead of Adama.

191

:

Like

192

:

Xhafer: Mm-hmm.

193

:

Yeah.

194

:

He's just in sick bay

as all this goes down.

195

:

Laura: he's so out of his element.

196

:

and the pilots come home.

197

:

Xhafer: Yes, they're all

celebrating because they blew up

198

:

the thing and they're all happy,

199

:

Laura: Yeah.

200

:

Xhafer: Apollo and the nuggets,

find centurions to theme, so

201

:

their enthusiasm quickly fades.

202

:

Laura: Yeah, Lee kind of knows

something is wrong because

203

:

he's like, we let one through.

204

:

You should not celebrate.

205

:

He says that to his pilots and like, we

are going to look to see what's going on.

206

:

Maybe it's the power goes out.

207

:

I can't remember exactly.

208

:

And yeah, they stumble on the centurions.

209

:

Xhafer: Cat hotdog and Apollo are saved by

Marines with their last explosive round.

210

:

They head to the BRI to get the president

to safety while CIC warns the fleet,

211

:

or at least attempts to warn the fleet

before communications are killed.

212

:

Laura: Yeah, so remember how we

needed Doc Coddle really bad.

213

:

Xhafer: Yeah,

214

:

Laura: We can't even let

him on the ship right

215

:

now.

216

:

like

217

:

Xhafer: It's like episodes

before a DAMA sees do coddle.

218

:

Laura: It's crazy.

219

:

Yeah.

220

:

Yeah.

221

:

We've had one episode where they

were just trying to get back to the

222

:

right area of space, and now we've

got episode two where they're trying

223

:

to get the battle bots off the ship,

224

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

225

:

Laura: disable all the

battle bots, like just wild.

226

:

Xhafer: Apollo gives Billy a

side arm and tasks Billy along

227

:

with Vermer, the np, Verner Vener

228

:

Laura: Oh wait, how did they get to there?

229

:

Xhafer: they, they went to the bri.

230

:

That was, they're like, okay, well Lee

knows the president's in the brick because

231

:

he's got the adjoining cell, right?

232

:

So he is like, okay, so let's go

make sure the president isn't dead

233

:

and get the president to safety.

234

:

Laura: Yeah.

235

:

I wanna see a like.

236

:

Ship plans or blueprints.

237

:

And so I know exactly where the

BRI was compared to this action.

238

:

Like they make it seem like the, the

BRI is in between two points that the

239

:

cys are interested in or something.

240

:

And so because Rosalyn and Billy

like hear gunfire in the bri,

241

:

so they're close.

242

:

Xhafer: I mean, it would make sense

to put it kind of in the center

243

:

of the ship so that you could get

people there from anywhere quickly.

244

:

Laura: That's a good point.

245

:

And then like they can't easily be

sprung from the middle of the ship.

246

:

Right.

247

:

If you have your bri along the

hull or something, that could be

248

:

a problem.

249

:

Xhafer: I mean, you might want

that so you can space them easy,

250

:

but that's a whole other thing.

251

:

Laura: Yeah.

252

:

That's a whole

253

:

Xhafer: the Roslyn Special

Break next to an airlock

254

:

Laura: And it's the gunshots

that gets Rosalyn to convince

255

:

the guard to let her out

256

:

Xhafer: yeah.

257

:

Laura: because like we are all

sitting ducks here, but maybe if we

258

:

can get moving then we might survive,

259

:

so,

260

:

Xhafer: Lee sends them to Sik Bay because

it is the safest place on the ship.

261

:

He, he rattles off a couple

of reasons really quick.

262

:

It's enclosed, it's meant

to act as a shelter, like,

263

:

Laura: Okay.

264

:

Xhafer: yeah.

265

:

Okay.

266

:

Sure.

267

:

Laura: I'll buy it.

268

:

It seems urgent.

269

:

We go somewhere

270

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

271

:

Uh, Sik Bay's actually made out of

entirely the black box material,

272

:

so it's meant to survive in case

the rest of the ship gets blown up.

273

:

Laura: Okay.

274

:

Xhafer: That's an, that's

an old Seinfeld joke.

275

:

Laura: Why, why don't they make the

planes out of the black box material?

276

:

Xhafer: 'cause it's too fucking heavy.

277

:

Not a concern in space.

278

:

Laura: True.

279

:

Yeah.

280

:

If you don't have landing craft, right.

281

:

Xhafer: They decided to head to

an arm's locker to look for more

282

:

explosive rounds, and this is when

we cut over to Caprica, yellow.

283

:

Starbuck and Hilo tried to

figure out a way off world.

284

:

Laura: She's so mad.

285

:

Xhafer: God, the look Hilo

gets when he says that he was

286

:

one step ahead of the cys.

287

:

A plus.

288

:

Katie sack off.

289

:

This is the best acting.

290

:

Ever.

291

:

Just like I, like, I mean,

suspending disbelief aside of

292

:

sci-fi and robots and all of that.

293

:

I was so bought in to, she was sick

of his bullshit from this one look.

294

:

Perfect.

295

:

Just like, oh, one step

ahead of the silence, Uhhuh.

296

:

Laura: Uh Huh.

297

:

Yeah, he's, he's starting to put

together like all the little cognitive

298

:

pieces that he had missed and having

to like unravel, like, wait, no.

299

:

I think he doesn't even like get it,

that like, he's like, she was so real,

300

:

like, like our Sharon, and he's not like.

301

:

Making the next step to like

our, Sharon wasn't real either.

302

:

Like

303

:

Yeah.

304

:

Xhafer: Versus Starbuck who the

second, she's like, oh, shit.

305

:

Laura: mm-hmm.

306

:

Xhafer: Immediately knows

that boomer's a problem.

307

:

Laura: But I guess maybe Hilo

wouldn't really have enough

308

:

information at this point.

309

:

Right?

310

:

Because he doesn't know

there's 12 models of

311

:

Cy.

312

:

Xhafer: yeah, his thing has been

that the silences have cloned humans.

313

:

Laura: Uh huh.

314

:

Xhafer: And are making them

do their bidding somehow.

315

:

Not that these are actually just Cy.

316

:

Laura: right.

317

:

He, he can't know that like, oh,

there wasn't a real person that Sharon

318

:

was based on, like, this is just.

319

:

Sharon Sharon's our all cylon.

320

:

He can't really know that with what

he's been given on that planet.

321

:

Yeah.

322

:

But he is mad at himself.

323

:

He's mad that he fell

in love with a machine.

324

:

Um, and she says that the CYS

make them all look like idiots.

325

:

I.

326

:

Xhafer: After this ties back in

CIC uh, he knows the silence plan.

327

:

He, you know.

328

:

Had done some shit, you know, first

silent war, et cetera, et cetera.

329

:

He's all like, no, they're going

to auxiliary gun control and

330

:

auxiliary damage control because

on this type of ship, those are not

331

:

particularly well protected sections.

332

:

And from there you can vent everyone

on the ship into space and then

333

:

kill everyone else around you.

334

:

That's the plan.

335

:

Laura: Yeah, that sucks.

336

:

I mean, I'm glad he's here to know that

I, I didn't realize he was like putting

337

:

things together from his past experience.

338

:

I thought they were just like all.

339

:

You know, like techno babbling together

and then suddenly we know the thing

340

:

and we explain it to everybody.

341

:

Xhafer: No, he, he looks at like

the path that they're heading in and

342

:

is and says, I've seen this before.

343

:

Like, I know exactly what

they're trying to do right now.

344

:

This is old s maneuvering.

345

:

This is

346

:

Laura: Yeah.

347

:

Xhafer: this is not fancy new cylon shit.

348

:

These, these chrome

domes aren't that much.

349

:

I mean, they're, they're deadlier.

350

:

They got claw hands.

351

:

They're gonna wolverine your ass,

352

:

but they're not that much different than

the silence he had previously encountered.

353

:

Laura: Yeah.

354

:

We can't have flashbacks of

whatever that was when he.

355

:

Felt that happen before, because we

just flashback to all the mustache

356

:

Adama in the episode before, so

357

:

Xhafer: Yeah, we don't even

see him in the military before.

358

:

Laura: Yeah, that's true.

359

:

We see him after military.

360

:

Yeah.

361

:

Xhafer: yeah, he gets

reinstated, like they use those

362

:

words, but who fucking knows

363

:

Laura: Yeah.

364

:

So over on cobol, we have Gais again at

the Raptor one crash site, and he's back

365

:

to Christing and hallucinating Adama.

366

:

This time

367

:

Xhafer: yeah.

368

:

Adama just comes in on this dream

sequence, pulls a snit ski and just

369

:

drop, kicks this baby into the river.

370

:

Laura: so GaiS thinks

he's holding this baby.

371

:

That was like revealed

in the last episode.

372

:

Right?

373

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

374

:

Laura: And I.

375

:

Adama asks to hold it and says, is

this the shape of things to come?

376

:

He asks him that, and I think

Gaas answers in the affirmative,

377

:

or maybe he doesn't answer.

378

:

I can't remember exactly.

379

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

380

:

He, it's, I think he says something

like, that's my understanding,

381

:

Laura: Yeah.

382

:

Yeah.

383

:

Xhafer: because I think he said

the same thing to six earlier.

384

:

Like two episodes

385

:

Laura: he

386

:

asked.

387

:

Yeah.

388

:

This is the shape of things to come.

389

:

Yeah.

390

:

Yeah.

391

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

392

:

Laura: And Gais, I guess, is like bought

in at least later in this episode.

393

:

It makes me think he's bought in, um,

into the robot baby because Adama goes

394

:

to drop, kick the baby into the river.

395

:

He's like chasing after him

desperately pleading not to

396

:

do the thing he's gonna do.

397

:

I'm so confused.

398

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

399

:

Adama, gets all biblical,

but forgets the basket.

400

:

it's uh, it's pretty,

it's, it's very jarring.

401

:

I mean, it's supposed to be jarring, like

the whole point of like, you know, it's a

402

:

dream immediately because Baltar is not in

the woods and Adama is there immediately.

403

:

They just showed us him in Sik Bay right

before, you know, like, that's fresh.

404

:

That wasn't an accident.

405

:

That was, that was to

remind us where he is.

406

:

So that way when we see this, we know

it's a dream before it gets started.

407

:

Laura: right.

408

:

Xhafer: And so when Adama just takes and.

409

:

Drowns this baby,

410

:

Laura: Yeah,

411

:

Xhafer: which we should probably throw

a content warning on this episode.

412

:

Actually,

413

:

Laura: This whole show

is a big content warning.

414

:

Like everything Battlestar

Galactica, just assume something

415

:

messed up is gonna happen.

416

:

Xhafer: we haven't even gotten

close to the worst of it.

417

:

Laura: Oh, yay.

418

:

So it seems like.

419

:

Maybe the stream sequence

is all metaphor too.

420

:

Like

421

:

Xhafer: Yes.

422

:

Laura: there's another drop for

you that, you know, it's, maybe

423

:

it's not even about real babies.

424

:

Like we know that Sharon supposedly

had gotten pregnant and there's real

425

:

robot human baby happening there, but.

426

:

It feels like six is warming gais to

the idea of like, we can live together

427

:

maybe in a sort of new human evolution.

428

:

Xhafer: Do the thing

429

:

instead of all of this happening

before happening again, maybe.

430

:

Laura: Yeah, I don't know, but, but

Adama will be a roadblock to that.

431

:

He will not accept this idea.

432

:

Xhafer: no, no.

433

:

no.

434

:

Adama is not down for the

shape of things to come.

435

:

Laura: yeah, so like, maybe you should

consider that Gais and he wakes up with

436

:

six PT there and he is totally crazed.

437

:

Xhafer: Yeah, he is hysterical.

438

:

Um, I.

439

:

And in the very literal sense, just

like freaking out cannot be calmed down.

440

:

Laura: Yeah.

441

:

He's like, he's, he drowned

our baby or something.

442

:

I think he says.

443

:

And uh, have you ever woken,

like totally crazed from a dream?

444

:

Xhafer: Um, I think we, we, if

we talk, I don't really dream.

445

:

Laura: Yeah, you have mentioned that

before, so you haven't done it then.

446

:

I guess

447

:

Xhafer: not, not that I recall.

448

:

Laura: I've, I can remember

one occasion very vividly,

449

:

Xhafer: Okay.

450

:

Laura: I had like hallucinated that

a giant spider had come down from the

451

:

ceiling, like, and landed on my pillow

452

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

453

:

Laura: right in front of

my face and I about ripped.

454

:

Like Aaron's arm off,

455

:

like crazed gaas, but mumbling

a yelling about a spider, like

456

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

457

:

Laura: real.

458

:

Xhafer: I don't know that I,

I've had dreams where like, they

459

:

are so stark, it wakes me up

460

:

and then I do not get

back to sleep very easily.

461

:

but most of the times when I have

a dream, it's my workday and I

462

:

go to work and I work all day.

463

:

And then I, when I'm getting

ready to leave work, I wake up

464

:

and then I have to go to work.

465

:

Laura: Yeah, no, my, my brain is working

through some shit and it's doing it in

466

:

graphic and colorful ways in the night.

467

:

Yeah.

468

:

Xhafer: Um, I'm jealous.

469

:

Incredibly jealous.

470

:

Laura: I don't know, man,

I don't think he should be.

471

:

Xhafer: you say that, but, I feel

like I'm missing out on like a

472

:

third of my life by not dreaming.

473

:

Laura: Aw.

474

:

Xhafer: Like, like really?

475

:

I, I, I'm in, I'm very jealous.

476

:

One of the highlights of my morning

is when Beth wakes up and I hear

477

:

about her dreams because I get to

experience that kind of, you know,

478

:

sensation and feeling secondhand.

479

:

I, because I don't get it

personally, very rarely.

480

:

Um, you know, maybe once every couple

of months I'll have a very mundane dream

481

:

and then maybe every couple of years

I will have a like vivid out there.

482

:

Dream.

483

:

Laura: Huh.

484

:

Wow.

485

:

Yeah, no, I'm working through

a lot of stuff all the time.

486

:

Like you shut off the, front end here.

487

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

488

:

Laura: You shut off the front end.

489

:

It's no longer operating, and then

the back is just like working away.

490

:

It's like we gotta, we gotta

work through this stupid thing

491

:

that Laura said at 2:00 PM

492

:

Xhafer: Remember three weeks ago when you

saw Spider, when you were doing laundry?

493

:

What if it was giant?

494

:

Laura: Yeah, so Gaia's Gaia's

front end is also been.

495

:

Deactivated and the rest is going crazy.

496

:

Um, he says that scripture is

a coverup for savagery when

497

:

they like see human skulls all

498

:

around them.

499

:

Xhafer: Yeah, cobol apparently

real big on the human sacrifice.

500

:

Laura: That's what 60 BT tells

501

:

him.

502

:

Xhafer: Yeah, I mean, all

that has happened before

503

:

Laura: Mm-hmm.

504

:

Xhafer: and will happen again presumably.

505

:

Laura: I don't know how much

I trust the history that six

506

:

PT is dropping here, though.

507

:

I don't

508

:

know.

509

:

Xhafer: That's very fair to question.

510

:

Laura: Did she just make it up?

511

:

What data was she trained on?

512

:

I

513

:

don't know.

514

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

515

:

Right.

516

:

With six PT.

517

:

Just trained on a bunch of conspiracy

theorists and Twitter posts.

518

:

Trash ai.

519

:

Get it outta here.

520

:

Garbage in, garbage out.

521

:

Uh, Lee and crew make their way to the

arms locker over piles of bodies to

522

:

find very few explosive rounds left.

523

:

Another team must have

come by and grabbed some.

524

:

Laura: Okay.

525

:

There's a lot of bodies in this episode.

526

:

Xhafer: yeah.

527

:

I mean, we see like there's like

40 dead people, which is a lot when

528

:

you're in the tens of thousands.

529

:

Laura: Yeah.

530

:

And they're, and you presumably,

like your whole population

531

:

is in the tens of thousands.

532

:

Right?

533

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

534

:

Laura: Only a fraction of

those are your military people.

535

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

536

:

Laura: So that is crazy.

537

:

And so they, they get into this arms

locker, the keypad doesn't work, but they,

538

:

they manage to get in and they come along.

539

:

This man called Gmer.

540

:

And he's, he's alone with a lot

of dead people in this arm's

541

:

locker, and I do not trust Jamer.

542

:

I am, I am worried about cylon here.

543

:

Xhafer: that's fair.

544

:

Laura: Uh, he's a

545

:

panicky

546

:

mess,

547

:

which,

548

:

Xhafer: to be, yeah, I think you're

supposed to think he's a silent,

549

:

because how could he have survived?

550

:

Laura: And they set up the same thing

later in the episode with someone else.

551

:

Uh, But yeah, I, I don't trust

Jamer even though he is a, a very

552

:

understandable, panicky mess.

553

:

Like, I don't think I would

necessarily be handling things

554

:

better than Jamer in this moment,

555

:

Xhafer: I I think if you're

handling things well,

556

:

. You're either very, very compartmentalized

or you need help so badly.

557

:

Laura: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

558

:

Xhafer: If you're that

compartmentalized, you should see up.

559

:

Laura: Yeah.

560

:

So I don't know, but I, I

definitely, you know, if I've got

561

:

my, like, possible cylons list,

562

:

jammer's

563

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

564

:

Jammer's name is on it.

565

:

Laura: Yep.

566

:

Xhafer: on the list of Laura.

567

:

Laura: So Star BE'S

breaks into her old place.

568

:

I guess she lived near Delphi.

569

:

Who knew?

570

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

571

:

Laura: I.

572

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

573

:

Uh, We see her place, we see

paintings of hers for the first

574

:

Laura: Yeah.

575

:

Lots of

576

:

big,

577

:

Xhafer: This, this will come back.

578

:

Uh, There's a giant

mural in her living room

579

:

Laura: Uhhuh.

580

:

Xhafer: that will, is important.

581

:

There's like stuff written

along the side of it.

582

:

It's important.

583

:

Um, it's not supposed

to be important yet, but

584

:

Laura: it will be,

585

:

Xhafer: It will be, they'll bring it back.

586

:

Don't worry.

587

:

Uh, It's, it.

588

:

Just remember that painting.

589

:

Set it aside for later.

590

:

Laura: Yep.

591

:

Xhafer: she listens to a recording of her

dad playing piano, find some cigars and

592

:

waxes poetic about her life before the

fall of the colonies compared to after.

593

:

Laura: Yeah.

594

:

So I guess this is probably

how we're gonna get more

595

:

cigars on Galactica eventually.

596

:

Right?

597

:

She's bringing 'em

598

:

back.

599

:

Xhafer: She did take a box with her.

600

:

We see it.

601

:

She's carrying one

602

:

Laura: it's.

603

:

It's nice to see us refill the torpedoes.

604

:

You know, Voyager's thing about

like, well we just got torpedoes.

605

:

Well, Starbuck has a

reason to have cigars.

606

:

Yeah.

607

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

608

:

Laura: so she tells Hilo that

she never missed any of this.

609

:

Everyone is fighting for what

they had, but she's just fighting

610

:

because she likes fighting.

611

:

Xhafer: Mm-hmm.

612

:

Laura: And do you know what

this music was that she puts on?

613

:

Xhafer: No.

614

:

Laura: So apparently it's Philip Glass

615

:

Xhafer: Okay.

616

:

Laura: and we keep playing it a

little bit through the episode.

617

:

I think like it, it's, we go

back to Galactica, I think,

618

:

and we're still hearing it.

619

:

Xhafer: bear McCreary at this point

is doing all of the music for the show

620

:

Laura: Uhhuh.

621

:

Xhafer: and there is nothing on accident.

622

:

Laura: Mm-hmm.

623

:

Xhafer: It's, it's all, it's, he's so

624

:

Laura: Yeah.

625

:

This Philip Glass was really good.

626

:

I was like, man, I'll, I'll look that up.

627

:

I'll listen to it.

628

:

But I think, I think Aaron said it's maybe

one of the only things that wasn't him.

629

:

Like maybe it's the only thing

that wasn't Bear McCreary.

630

:

Yeah.

631

:

Xhafer: uh, spoilers, um,

632

:

The, uh, president's cohort runs into D

633

:

Laura: More dead

634

:

Xhafer: a very, very bad day.

635

:

Yeah.

636

:

Laura: So many more dead

637

:

bodies.

638

:

Xhafer: So many more dead bodies.

639

:

D is full on traumatized

640

:

Laura: Yes.

641

:

So interesting that Rosalyn, like

as Billy is trying to reach Dee

642

:

and, and like Dee Dee, listen to me

Rosalyn says, try petty Officer Doa

643

:

and that does snap her out of it.

644

:

Xhafer: Yeah,

645

:

Laura: So weird.

646

:

Yeah.

647

:

But, and the corporal who I

believe he was the guard and

648

:

he's been traveling with them.

649

:

Is that right?

650

:

Xhafer: Werner

651

:

Laura: I didn't catch a name.

652

:

I just caught the title of

653

:

Corporal.

654

:

Yeah.

655

:

Xhafer: I just know it

from the, uh, subtitles.

656

:

Laura: Oh, okay.

657

:

Yeah.

658

:

He's struggling, responding to her

as well, seeing all these, these,

659

:

dead bodies.

660

:

Xhafer: Yeah, it's a lot.

661

:

Laura: 'cause I think we're, again,

we've kind of set up this person here

662

:

alone with all these dead bodies.

663

:

Could they be a asylum?

664

:

And also she's acting weird

'cause she's not able to speak.

665

:

Oh, is she a silent?

666

:

But then also this corporal

can't speak either.

667

:

So like, I don't know.

668

:

Can't think either.

669

:

Xhafer: Are they all silences?

670

:

Laura: Or is nobody a silent?

671

:

Oh my God,

672

:

Xhafer: That's not the case.

673

:

Spoilers.

674

:

Um,

675

:

Laura: yeah.

676

:

There's more silents here somewhere.

677

:

I'm sure.

678

:

Xhafer: Up in CNC we learned the silents

have cut through the hole to prevent

679

:

being followed in certain places.

680

:

Uh, And this is when Saul

calls out to smoke 'em.

681

:

If you got 'em

682

:

just like, uh, Well this might be it.

683

:

Laura: Nothing between the last

two silos and those safeties.

684

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

685

:

Laura: Oh.

686

:

Xhafer: Can't you just like.

687

:

Plug that networked computer in

or something to prevent this gada.

688

:

Don't you have a cord from that computer

running to your terminal right now?

689

:

Can't you just delete that

terminal or some shit real quick?

690

:

Laura: Right.

691

:

Get the network computer

on to take it down.

692

:

Xhafer: Just like you don't have to

do all of them, but just that one.

693

:

Laura: Yeah.

694

:

Xhafer: Uh.

695

:

This is when we go back to cobol, the

chief and Kelly yell out some of their

696

:

frustrations working their way back.

697

:

Sinus is too far gone for the

medicine at this point, so they move

698

:

from trying to keep him alive to

double dors Moora to ease his pain.

699

:

Laura: This sucks.

700

:

There's so much here that sucks.

701

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

702

:

Laura: You know.

703

:

Obviously Callie and Terl

have been through a lot just

704

:

to get this stuff back right.

705

:

And S's position is, is real bad.

706

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

707

:

Laura: but crash down

is a freaking coward.

708

:

you know, he's been all

like I am in charge.

709

:

And the second, like some

chips are really down.

710

:

He's like, no, Tyrell, he's your man.

711

:

You make the decision.

712

:

Xhafer: Yep.

713

:

Laura: Which on the one hand, like,

okay, maybe, maybe Tyrell might

714

:

feel like, yeah, I do need to be

the one that makes the decision.

715

:

But all this time you've been

like, I'm the big dog, and now

716

:

you're like, Nope, nope, nope.

717

:

Not the big dog here.

718

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

719

:

No.

720

:

No, not when they're not.

721

:

When I might feel bad about my decision.

722

:

Either way, I'm gonna feel bad about

my decision, so I don't wanna make it.

723

:

No,

724

:

Laura: Yeah, I'm mad at crash down for

725

:

this.

726

:

Xhafer: that's fair.

727

:

Laura: So yes, Tyrell decides that

if the, he doesn't wanna believe the

728

:

medic at first, that there's no way he

can be saved, but he does decide that

729

:

this is his man, he is gonna do

this, and he like lies to him about

730

:

rescue as he gives him the drugs.

731

:

Just so very sad.

732

:

This sucks.

733

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

734

:

yeah, it's bad.

735

:

Apollo calls into CIC and happens

to hear, uh, where he needs to be.

736

:

Uh, like he happens to be in the

area of the ship where he might

737

:

have a chance at saving them.

738

:

Laura: Yeah, they're like between

the silences and the decompression.

739

:

Safeties by

740

:

Xhafer: so so Ty's just like,

you need to fucking get there.

741

:

Right Fucking now.

742

:

Laura: Yeah.

743

:

Xhafer: The, uh, president's group gets

stuck 20 meters from Sikh Bay here,

744

:

and they run into the aforementioned

decompressed hallway uh, which is

745

:

why they can't open up that door.

746

:

So they have to pass through,

aft damage control the silence

747

:

target in order to reach Sikh Bay.

748

:

Laura: Cool.

749

:

Yeah.

750

:

And we are finding all this out as also

Billy is like showing the audience that

751

:

he is not capable by sticking the gun

in his pants without the safety on.

752

:

Xhafer: Y.

753

:

Laura: Yeah.

754

:

Like we have VIN here and he's

got the training and a gun and

755

:

that's great, but our other dude

with a gun is not good at it.

756

:

Does Dallah even have a weapon at this

757

:

point?

758

:

Xhafer: Um,

759

:

I

760

:

don't,

761

:

I don't think so given she's

like trying to give pointers on

762

:

how to use the weapon to Billy,

763

:

which was weird.

764

:

You'd think, I mean, maybe she is just

too, too traumatized at the moment,

765

:

um, to,

766

:

to

767

:

Laura: a steady hand or, yeah.

768

:

Xhafer: but that would be my,

if I were Billy here, like

769

:

Laura: maybe you should

770

:

Xhafer: maybe you should have this.

771

:

It's not even like It's got an explosive

round, they're not gonna do anything.

772

:

Laura: what, what a vivid and perfect

way to tell the audience that like,

773

:

this fool should not have this thing.

774

:

Xhafer: Yeah,

775

:

Laura: It's perfect.

776

:

Xhafer: yeah.

777

:

The uh, you're gonna shoot your dick off

on accident is, uh, big warning signs.

778

:

Laura: So Owen was like in the

room while we watched this episode.

779

:

He kind of does his own thing

when we're watching Battlestar.

780

:

He's not super interested in it, but

at this point, as I was like pausing

781

:

to write my notes, I was like, Owen,

never stick a gun in your pants.

782

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

783

:

Laura: It's,

784

:

like important life lesson right now.

785

:

Xhafer: it's, it's never cool.

786

:

Laura: Never do it.

787

:

Never, never do it.

788

:

Xhafer: Lee and team cover outside of

AF Damage Control as both groups here

789

:

gunfire and screaming in the distance.

790

:

Lee quotes, his dad gotta roll

the hard six and then says he

791

:

doesn't know what it means.

792

:

I have been convinced I know what it

means for forever, and I don't know

793

:

if that's a spoiler for later or if

it's something that I had already made

794

:

up by the time this episode aired.

795

:

Laura: I mean, I've heard people

talk about rolling a hard six

796

:

before, like in context, that

weren't Battlestar Galactica.

797

:

Xhafer: I, I do believe

it comes from this show.

798

:

Laura: No,

799

:

really,

800

:

it's nothing to do with craps.

801

:

Xhafer: No, you, no, you don't.

802

:

Six is not a, you don't,

no, that's not in craps.

803

:

Laura: I don't know.

804

:

I just thought maybe craps has a ton of

rules that I don't understand 'em all.

805

:

Xhafer: Fair enough.

806

:

So I have always been under the impression

that rolling the hards six is when they

807

:

do the flippy thing in the ship because

you press the nose down at six o'clock.

808

:

Right to flip the

809

:

Laura: I think we have

talked about this before.

810

:

Okay.

811

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

812

:

Yeah.

813

:

He, well, we've heard it before and I

always assumed that's what it meant.

814

:

And I don't know if I am now remembering

something that happens later in the show

815

:

or am, uh, just hadn't come up with that

answer, apropos of nothing at some point.

816

:

Laura: Huh, okay.

817

:

According to Google ai, which, eh.

818

:

Xhafer: Fuck that, but what do we got?

819

:

Laura: It says in the

context of Dice game craps.

820

:

So,

821

:

Xhafer: Oh,

822

:

Laura: uh,

823

:

Rolling a hard six means

rolling a six with two dice,

824

:

specifically a pair of threes.

825

:

Xhafer: Okay.

826

:

Laura: So, I don't know.

827

:

Could be right, could be wrong, but I was

like, I feel like, I feel like it's craps.

828

:

Xhafer: Scroll down just a little bit.

829

:

Laura: Uh, There's definitely a

Reddit about Battlestar Galactica,

830

:

which I am not scrolling too

831

:

far

832

:

Xhafer: Oh, okay.

833

:

That's fair.

834

:

Don't, Yeah.

835

:

yeah,

836

:

Why'd you Google it?

837

:

Why that's safe space?

838

:

Laura: Well, okay.

839

:

Urban Dictionary also agrees

with, with the Google AI that

840

:

the phrase originates from craps.

841

:

Xhafer: Well, it's probably not

agreeing with so much as it was

842

:

Laura: Google AI took it

from Urban Dictionary.

843

:

Yeah.

844

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

845

:

turning the tables when the pursuer,

when being chased is what the

846

:

Battlestar Galactica one says.

847

:

Laura: Oh, I mean that's probably

referring to this episode then, right?

848

:

Because we're like trying to turn the

tables on these silents and no longer

849

:

be chased because this, we're about

ready to have our like last stand.

850

:

Xhafer: Okay, so.

851

:

I see the quote attributed to Adama,

but also referring to craps in the

852

:

same sentence because apparently

rolling a pair of threes paste seven

853

:

to one, which is good for craps.

854

:

Laura: Yeah, it has a ton of rules, right?

855

:

Xhafer: It's almost like it's

designed to be archaic, unknowable,

856

:

and unwinnable on purpose.

857

:

What a casino game, what.

858

:

No one knows how to play Bach.

859

:

I don't want to hear it.

860

:

Laura: I don't even, craps is my limit.

861

:

That's, I find craps interesting to watch.

862

:

I don't think I would find

Bette interesting to watch

863

:

just based on the name.

864

:

Xhafer: I think most things

aren't interesting to watch,

865

:

just generally speaking.

866

:

Laura: Okay.

867

:

But this last stand is interesting to

watch 'cause we have, jamer and Lee

868

:

like setting up for their last stand.

869

:

Jamer is clearly like not,

also not qualified for this.

870

:

He's big old coward at this moment.

871

:

and it's gotta be a headshot.

872

:

This explosive round

has to go to the head.

873

:

And there are two of them.

874

:

Two silence,

875

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

876

:

It's where aerobic brains are.

877

:

Laura: right?

878

:

How about the whole robot is the brain?

879

:

That seems like an idea.

880

:

so Rosalyn and Co are like down

the hallway a little bit, right?

881

:

Xhafer: mm-hmm.

882

:

Laura: They're set up Lee and Jamer,

and I think another guy are right

883

:

outside of AFT damage control.

884

:

The CYS come charging through.

885

:

they run right past Rosalyn and

the team, but Billy fucks it up.

886

:

Xhafer: Billy does fuck it up

887

:

Laura: He, he like accidentally

shoots a shot, right?

888

:

Just a wild shot.

889

:

Uh, and so

890

:

Xhafer: He's trying and just fucks

up and shouldn't have the gun.

891

:

Laura: right.

892

:

So the silence stop running at

Lee and team, and now they're

893

:

shooting at Roslyn and Company and

get shot at from behind by Lee.

894

:

So he gets one or he or his team get one.

895

:

Xhafer: Mm-hmm.

896

:

Laura: But they keep missing

the headshot on the other.

897

:

And this last battle bot comes

like charging at Lee and he

898

:

barely gets it in the head.

899

:

Just in time.

900

:

Xhafer: Yep.

901

:

It's a little miracle.

902

:

Laura: So at the end of the scene,

I wrote Rosalyn, Billy, and Co.

903

:

Fine.

904

:

Jamer has to be silent.

905

:

Oh.

906

:

But interesting that we've got

this particular guard here that

907

:

was kind of feeling away about

Rosalyn in the last episode.

908

:

Right.

909

:

He, he calls her a prophet

910

:

Xhafer: Mm-hmm.

911

:

Prays with her, does the thing.

912

:

Laura: Prays with her lets

her out in this episode.

913

:

And now he sees on her blazer

that she almost got shot, like

914

:

a bullet went right through

915

:

the

916

:

Xhafer: Yeah, like just,

just grazed her suit, coat.

917

:

Yeah.

918

:

Laura: Hmm.

919

:

I wonder if that will come up later.

920

:

Xhafer: Does that make you more

suspicious that she's a silent?

921

:

Laura: I don't know.

922

:

I, I, I, I could believe this

is all coincidence and that it's

923

:

just gonna get really out of hand.

924

:

'cause now we have this person

here who maybe goes a little bit

925

:

zealot for her cause, you know,

926

:

Xhafer: Okay.

927

:

I wanna talk about this more,

but I wanna talk about it in the

928

:

broader scope of not this episode.

929

:

So let's finish up this

930

:

Laura: okay.

931

:

We don't have much left.

932

:

We go back to uh, Caprica

for just a minute, for SPS to

933

:

get a hold of her old trek.

934

:

Xhafer: Yep.

935

:

It's got Delphi plates.

936

:

Love it.

937

:

This is the attention to detail

I'm here for always scoping them.

938

:

License plates.

939

:

Laura: Yeah.

940

:

Glad to see license plates.

941

:

Make it to the future, right?

942

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

943

:

Billy hangs out with D in Sik Bay.

944

:

And, uh, she, they, they kiss, she,

she kind of makes up a bit, was

945

:

like, I was kind of shitty and it's

been a very bad day and you did

946

:

try and do the right thing today.

947

:

Laura: yeah.

948

:

Like, sorry I kicked you in the nuts.

949

:

You did your best.

950

:

yeah,

951

:

Xhafer: yeah, like maybe

we can make this work.

952

:

try and get us some privacy.

953

:

Laura: It's pretty cute.

954

:

Yeah.

955

:

Ty Lee and Rosalyn are all watching

over Adama, and we found out

956

:

Doc Coddle is on his way again.

957

:

Xhafer: Yep.

958

:

Laura: And Rosalyn tells Ty

she's ready to return to her

959

:

cell, and Ty is like, okay, fine.

960

:

No chains of hearts here.

961

:

Xhafer: he gives Lee some shit

for siting with the president.

962

:

And Lee is just like, I don't

give a fuck about your judgment.

963

:

I give a fuck about

the old man's judgment.

964

:

Nothing else is gonna fucking matter here.

965

:

So say whatever you want.

966

:

I don't, I don't give a

967

:

Laura: yeah.

968

:

I might not be fit to wear this uniform,

but you definitely aren't either.

969

:

So we'll see what dad

says when he wakes up.

970

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

971

:

How badly you have fucked up here.

972

:

Laura: Yeah.

973

:

Xhafer: And that's to credits.

974

:

Laura: it, man.

975

:

That's

976

:

Xhafer: So on a scale of one to 12

colonies, how'd you feel about this one?

977

:

Laura: Well, if this one is the,

like 33 of the season, which I don't

978

:

know if it is or not, but it didn't

quite hit the same mark for me as 33.

979

:

Xhafer: It does not.

980

:

Laura: Yeah.

981

:

I can feel them like wanting me to be

suspicious of a whole bunch of people.

982

:

Xhafer: Yeah.

983

:

Laura: And I have no idea who's a asylum.

984

:

it would be really, I find poetic

if one of these people in this

985

:

episode is a silent, but we

will see, only time will tell.

986

:

Xhafer: Okay.

987

:

Laura: So, Hmm.

988

:

I don't know.

989

:

I think I can still give it a

990

:

10.

991

:

Xhafer: Yeah, I give it an eight.

992

:

Um, it has its fun moments.

993

:

Um, it felt a little bodily.

994

:

And, part of it is just

knowing how the next couple of

995

:

episodes are going to be spent.

996

:

Laura: Mm-hmm.

997

:

Xhafer: I think we, maybe

this episode could have been.

998

:

Cut for the most part.

999

:

And we could have sped up that arc

and maybe had some more space around

:

00:44:00,152 --> 00:44:07,112

episode 10 11, I would've liked so,

but that's all way in the future.

:

00:44:07,682 --> 00:44:12,842

What's near in the future is season

two, episode three, fragmented democracy

:

00:44:13,292 --> 00:44:16,982

bras brought back to the fleet,

and with it come hardball politics

:

00:44:17,252 --> 00:44:19,982

and potentially deadly intrigue.

:

00:44:20,547 --> 00:44:21,237

Laura: Hmm.

:

00:44:22,069 --> 00:44:23,629

Xhafer: So that's,

that's our next episode.

:

00:44:23,817 --> 00:44:25,287

Laura: I don't like the politics.

:

00:44:25,287 --> 00:44:26,022

It feels bad.

:

00:44:28,969 --> 00:44:32,119

Xhafer: can't we just have

normal politics please?

:

00:44:33,139 --> 00:44:34,069

Please.

:

00:44:34,579 --> 00:44:37,189

I don't want Roslyn to start

giving everyone tariffs.

:

00:44:37,399 --> 00:44:38,389

It's gonna be weird.

:

00:44:38,419 --> 00:44:40,099

There's not even any foreign countries.

:

00:44:42,042 --> 00:44:42,432

Laura: Tariff.

:

00:44:42,432 --> 00:44:42,582

The

:

00:44:42,769 --> 00:44:43,339

Xhafer: sense.

:

00:44:44,059 --> 00:44:45,919

Tariff these silence to hell.

:

00:44:46,286 --> 00:44:47,936

You don't buy anything from them.

:

00:44:47,936 --> 00:44:48,896

Exactly.

:

00:44:48,896 --> 00:44:51,356

We won't buy anything from, okay.

:

00:44:51,896 --> 00:44:52,406

So

:

00:44:52,698 --> 00:44:53,493

Laura: You wanna talk about

:

00:44:53,606 --> 00:44:55,286

Xhafer: about Cy.

:

00:44:55,886 --> 00:44:58,616

I wanna talk about who you

think is a CY right now.

:

00:44:59,306 --> 00:44:59,456

We're a

:

00:44:59,508 --> 00:45:01,338

Laura: you're gonna make me do this again.

:

00:45:02,156 --> 00:45:05,786

Xhafer: I just, I'm curious where we're at

right now, where your thoughts are, if you

:

00:45:05,786 --> 00:45:23,799

had to pick, like just pick a character

that you think is a silo, just 1D.

:

00:45:25,560 --> 00:45:26,490

Laura: I don't know.

:

00:45:26,910 --> 00:45:28,290

I'm a little afraid for Dee.

:

00:45:29,250 --> 00:45:35,190

I'm also afraid for Rosalyn, but

I'm also afraid for Adama like that.

:

00:45:35,190 --> 00:45:38,610

Adama could be potentially

like the anti sile.

:

00:45:38,610 --> 00:45:43,326

That's like their purpose is to like.

:

00:45:45,396 --> 00:45:48,906

Guide humanity in some way that

like forces some evolution.

:

00:45:48,906 --> 00:45:51,276

I'm just really on this

forced evolution thing.

:

00:45:51,276 --> 00:45:53,286

Like I'm stuck in shadows land.

:

00:45:54,199 --> 00:45:55,309

I don't know.

:

00:45:55,931 --> 00:45:59,981

Xhafer: I think you look about the

most uncomfortable I've ever seen.

:

00:45:59,981 --> 00:46:01,991

You look after asking you a question,

:

00:46:04,504 --> 00:46:07,894

Laura: Yeah, like we can talk about

the weirdest, most personal things,

:

00:46:07,894 --> 00:46:09,214

but you're like, who's a silent?

:

00:46:09,214 --> 00:46:10,144

And I'm like, God, I don't

:

00:46:10,331 --> 00:46:11,141

Xhafer: Fuck.

:

00:46:13,091 --> 00:46:14,016

Don't make me answer that.

:

00:46:16,556 --> 00:46:17,216

Sorry.

:

00:46:18,034 --> 00:46:20,254

Laura: Especially the ones that

you're getting to, like, like,

:

00:46:20,284 --> 00:46:22,804

obviously I, I even though.

:

00:46:23,329 --> 00:46:25,249

They're not getting along and

:

00:46:26,201 --> 00:46:26,621

Xhafer: Mm-hmm.

:

00:46:26,659 --> 00:46:28,459

Laura: both made some bad choices.

:

00:46:28,459 --> 00:46:30,349

Like, I like Adama and I like

:

00:46:30,349 --> 00:46:30,979

Rosalyn.

:

00:46:31,856 --> 00:46:32,216

Xhafer: Okay.

:

00:46:32,299 --> 00:46:32,659

Laura: And

:

00:46:32,659 --> 00:46:33,799

so like that

:

00:46:33,866 --> 00:46:35,276

Xhafer: Who did you pick last time?

:

00:46:35,516 --> 00:46:37,466

Last time I asked You

had a couple other names.

:

00:46:37,466 --> 00:46:38,096

You're footing around.

:

00:46:39,341 --> 00:46:40,391

Laura: I don't remember.

:

00:46:41,223 --> 00:46:41,583

Xhafer: Okay.

:

00:46:41,621 --> 00:46:44,591

Laura: I feel like Starbuck is not,

I think, I think what I did was

:

00:46:44,591 --> 00:46:46,151

like, here's who I think it's not.

:

00:46:46,151 --> 00:46:49,091

And then you were like, well, maybe it is.

:

00:46:49,773 --> 00:46:54,963

Xhafer: it's, yeah, so I mean, Starbuck

feels like, you know, like her home on

:

00:46:54,963 --> 00:46:57,123

Delphi, like that, that seems pretty safe.

:

00:46:57,663 --> 00:46:58,503

Um,

:

00:46:59,553 --> 00:47:01,263

although there's no

food there that's weird.

:

00:47:01,623 --> 00:47:02,283

Um.

:

00:47:03,618 --> 00:47:05,088

What about like Gais?

:

00:47:05,538 --> 00:47:08,718

Is there at any point any suspicion

about Gais being a silent?

:

00:47:08,996 --> 00:47:09,716

Laura: No.

:

00:47:09,948 --> 00:47:14,358

Xhafer: He's probably like the

least like, because they literally

:

00:47:14,358 --> 00:47:17,628

had to put silent agents around him

to do the shit they needed to do.

:

00:47:17,756 --> 00:47:20,606

Laura: Like you would've just had

him do the shit you needed to do.

:

00:47:20,696 --> 00:47:21,626

Like Yeah.

:

00:47:21,956 --> 00:47:22,526

That doesn't

:

00:47:22,578 --> 00:47:24,528

Xhafer: it'd be really

weird if he was a silent.

:

00:47:24,528 --> 00:47:24,858

Yeah.

:

00:47:25,046 --> 00:47:25,496

Laura: Right.

:

00:47:25,746 --> 00:47:27,726

Lee feels like not a Slon

:

00:47:29,051 --> 00:47:29,271

Lee.

:

00:47:29,316 --> 00:47:34,716

Starbuck Gais are the ones that I

now feel are like, probably not s.

:

00:47:35,824 --> 00:47:40,084

Although if, you know, if Adama's,

not cylon, but Lee is cylon, that

:

00:47:40,084 --> 00:47:43,177

could be, you know, big, big if

:

00:47:43,379 --> 00:47:44,999

Xhafer: that'd be, that'd be weird.

:

00:47:44,999 --> 00:47:45,299

Yeah.

:

00:47:45,607 --> 00:47:45,757

Laura: Mm-hmm.

:

00:47:46,409 --> 00:47:48,059

Xhafer: It feels like you'd

have to go through some fucking

:

00:47:48,059 --> 00:47:49,499

hoops to make that work.

:

00:47:49,687 --> 00:47:50,107

Laura: Yeah.

:

00:47:50,977 --> 00:47:55,837

You would've had to base the cy off

of real person in that case, because

:

00:47:55,837 --> 00:47:57,967

Lee was definitely a real person.

:

00:47:58,027 --> 00:47:58,327

So

:

00:47:59,249 --> 00:47:59,519

Xhafer: Yeah.

:

00:47:59,797 --> 00:48:00,427

Laura: I don't know.

:

00:48:01,027 --> 00:48:01,537

I don't know.

:

00:48:02,159 --> 00:48:03,569

Xhafer: I mean, unless

they're both silents.

:

00:48:04,612 --> 00:48:08,362

Laura: Yeah, that seems,

it seems like a bridge too

:

00:48:08,362 --> 00:48:08,722

far.

:

00:48:09,622 --> 00:48:10,702

So I don't know.

:

00:48:11,505 --> 00:48:11,865

We shall

:

00:48:11,865 --> 00:48:12,195

see.

:

00:48:13,073 --> 00:48:13,403

Xhafer: Yeah.

:

00:48:13,831 --> 00:48:16,021

Laura: I hope we get some

kind of reveal in season two.

:

00:48:16,021 --> 00:48:17,551

'cause like there's 12 of them in total.

:

00:48:17,551 --> 00:48:17,851

Right.

:

00:48:17,851 --> 00:48:23,131

And we have Bin Sharon six Dole.

:

00:48:23,731 --> 00:48:24,451

We only have four.

:

00:48:25,568 --> 00:48:31,038

Xhafer: You are going to

meet more Cylons this season?

:

00:48:31,206 --> 00:48:31,496

Laura: Okay.

:

00:48:32,628 --> 00:48:41,030

Xhafer: I want to say I think there

are one or two characters that are

:

00:48:41,030 --> 00:48:45,080

Cylons that I think they're either

introduced as cylons or found

:

00:48:45,080 --> 00:48:46,940

out to be silent very quickly.

:

00:48:47,443 --> 00:48:47,893

Laura: Okay.

:

00:48:48,583 --> 00:48:49,033

Yeah, I'm,

:

00:48:49,033 --> 00:48:50,323

I'm itching for more silent.

:

00:48:50,345 --> 00:48:50,495

Xhafer: even

:

00:48:50,495 --> 00:48:51,185

met yet.

:

00:48:51,335 --> 00:48:56,345

like like some of these are not

even, like, it's not like all 12 are

:

00:48:56,585 --> 00:48:58,355

characters you've interacted with.

:

00:48:58,548 --> 00:48:58,838

Laura: Yeah.

:

00:48:59,656 --> 00:49:00,106

Xhafer: You know?

:

00:49:00,496 --> 00:49:03,676

Uh, That's, I'll just

say that's not the case.

:

00:49:03,676 --> 00:49:07,846

You're not looking for eight

sirens in the fleet right now.

:

00:49:08,386 --> 00:49:10,546

Um, that's not how this goes.

:

00:49:10,546 --> 00:49:14,566

Like there are silents that just haven't

shown up yet for whatever reasons.

:

00:49:15,256 --> 00:49:16,546

There, there are reasons.

:

00:49:16,719 --> 00:49:17,009

Laura: Yeah.

:

00:49:18,414 --> 00:49:23,274

I really want l and Ty to be a salon and

to get her comeuppance in a dramatic way,

:

00:49:23,274 --> 00:49:24,834

but I don't think I'm gonna get that.

:

00:49:24,924 --> 00:49:26,844

I bet she's just a bad human.

:

00:49:29,072 --> 00:49:30,122

Xhafer: Can't say anything.

:

00:49:34,855 --> 00:49:37,975

Laura: Well, I'm, I'm itching for

more silent, like I was really hoping

:

00:49:37,975 --> 00:49:40,165

in the last season, you know, that.

:

00:49:41,005 --> 00:49:46,465

Because we knew all along about

Boomer that we'd also get like,

:

00:49:46,465 --> 00:49:51,115

surprise also this person, and we

didn't, so I'm, I'm just, I want it.

:

00:49:52,615 --> 00:49:52,735

I'm

:

00:49:52,892 --> 00:49:55,412

Xhafer: I mean, that twist is coming.

:

00:49:56,095 --> 00:49:56,395

Laura: Okay.

:

00:49:57,527 --> 00:49:59,897

Xhafer: Like you, that that,

that, that is a thing that

:

00:49:59,897 --> 00:50:01,757

happens that will have payoff.

:

00:50:02,087 --> 00:50:04,667

It might not be exactly how

you're imagining it right

:

00:50:04,667 --> 00:50:08,507

now, but that is a thing that

happens and you will be shocked.

:

00:50:08,600 --> 00:50:08,890

Laura: Cool.

:

00:50:09,745 --> 00:50:10,315

I'm excited.

:

00:50:11,087 --> 00:50:11,357

Xhafer: Yeah.

:

00:50:11,575 --> 00:50:11,995

Laura: Let's keep

:

00:50:11,995 --> 00:50:12,385

watching.

:

00:50:13,217 --> 00:50:13,517

Xhafer: Yeah.

:

00:50:13,547 --> 00:50:14,387

I mean, that's the plan.

:

00:50:14,867 --> 00:50:19,511

So we'll be back next week with

season two episode three, but before

:

00:50:19,511 --> 00:50:22,398

we get there, gotta say thank you.

:

00:50:22,998 --> 00:50:23,808

To Jeremy Siegel.

:

00:50:23,808 --> 00:50:25,518

Hey, Jeremy, how you doing?

:

00:50:26,508 --> 00:50:30,498

You just put out a bunch of recordings

it looks like from your Facebooks.

:

00:50:30,948 --> 00:50:32,658

Um, super happy for you.

:

00:50:33,680 --> 00:50:36,590

Uh, I'm glad that you're getting

to do so much music stuff.

:

00:50:36,590 --> 00:50:39,740

I know it brings you a lot of joy

and your music brings me a lot of

:

00:50:39,740 --> 00:50:41,150

joy and our audience, a lot of joy.

:

00:50:41,180 --> 00:50:42,890

Thanks so much for making our theme music.

:

00:50:42,890 --> 00:50:45,290

Appreciate the hell out of it and

appreciate the hell outta you.

:

00:50:45,920 --> 00:50:46,430

Thanks, Jeremy.

:

00:50:47,098 --> 00:50:50,158

Laura: Yeah, I have actually been

listening to our podcast again lately.

:

00:50:50,158 --> 00:50:53,788

I had kind of not 'cause I didn't

like the sound of my own voice, but

:

00:50:53,848 --> 00:50:55,408

all of a sudden I don't care anymore.

:

00:50:55,408 --> 00:51:00,628

And every time the theme comes on, before

we start talking, I get really excited.

:

00:51:00,748 --> 00:51:01,348

It's quite good.

:

00:51:01,475 --> 00:51:02,975

Xhafer: Yeah, good.

:

00:51:03,568 --> 00:51:06,238

Laura: And thank you to angry

Duck time machine on Instagram

:

00:51:06,238 --> 00:51:07,408

for our podcast artwork.

:

00:51:08,082 --> 00:51:11,772

Xhafer: Aaron, I know I gave you

some fucking out there drops today.

:

00:51:12,672 --> 00:51:16,002

I hope you found them, and if you

didn't, I know you spent a bunch

:

00:51:16,002 --> 00:51:18,822

of time looking for him and I

appreciate the hell out of that.

:

00:51:18,822 --> 00:51:20,712

Thanks for editing this podcast.

:

00:51:21,440 --> 00:51:26,270

Laura: And thank you listener for being

here with us as I am yet again confused by

:

00:51:26,300 --> 00:51:28,970

what is happening in Battlestar Galactica.

:

00:51:29,540 --> 00:51:32,840

If you know what is happening in

Battlestar Galactica and you wanna

:

00:51:32,840 --> 00:51:36,830

talk about it, go to our discord

and ask to be put in spoiler

:

00:51:36,830 --> 00:51:37,370

town.

:

00:51:38,097 --> 00:51:39,027

Xhafer: Yeah.

:

00:51:39,057 --> 00:51:40,287

We're talking spoiler town.

:

00:51:40,287 --> 00:51:42,657

I'm gonna be posting

in Spoiler Town things.

:

00:51:42,657 --> 00:51:45,567

You said this episode in about 10 minutes.

:

00:51:45,807 --> 00:51:46,137

So.

:

00:51:46,220 --> 00:51:46,440

Laura: no.

:

00:51:49,002 --> 00:51:52,392

Xhafer: It's gonna be like, we're

gonna finish this show and you're

:

00:51:52,392 --> 00:51:56,892

gonna get added to Spoiler Town and

you are just gonna scroll back two

:

00:51:56,892 --> 00:52:01,092

years and just read and it's gonna be.

:

00:52:02,082 --> 00:52:04,302

It starts with me apologizing.

:

00:52:04,452 --> 00:52:07,062

I think that's one of the

first posts in Spoiler Town

:

00:52:08,375 --> 00:52:10,055

Laura: Yay.

:

00:52:10,602 --> 00:52:14,142

Xhafer: for a thing that I said in

a very early episode of this run

:

00:52:16,715 --> 00:52:17,465

Laura: Cool.

:

00:52:18,035 --> 00:52:18,725

Yeah,

:

00:52:18,732 --> 00:52:22,417

Xhafer: not to not give away

something far later in the show.

:

00:52:24,755 --> 00:52:25,595

Laura: I can't wait.

:

00:52:26,262 --> 00:52:26,622

Xhafer: Yeah,

:

00:52:26,765 --> 00:52:28,055

Laura: Where's my time machine?

:

00:52:29,257 --> 00:52:30,277

Xhafer: well, we'll get there.

:

00:52:30,337 --> 00:52:31,987

uh, in a matter of time.

:

00:52:32,617 --> 00:52:32,947

All right.

:

00:52:32,947 --> 00:52:33,697

Thanks, listener.

:

00:52:33,727 --> 00:52:34,687

We'll see you next week.

:

00:52:35,010 --> 00:52:35,670

Laura: Bye.

Show artwork for Who Are You?

About the Podcast

Who Are You?
A Babylon 5 Watchcast
Join Laura and Xhafer, two internet strangers as they get to know each other while making jokes about one of their favorite TV shows from their childhood, Babylon 5.